Search This Blog

Counter

Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts

Sunday, December 5, 2010

Leroux and Global Warming

For a change of pace I have added Marcel Leroux's Global Warming - Myth Or Reality? to my bedtime reading. I don't recall why I chose this particular climate book from the shelf, but it is published by Springer, a publishing house respected by most mathematicians. In general it is difficult for an outsider to establish the reliability of a putative expert in a distant field. In fields in which I have some expertise, I frequently see the media promote extremely marginal scientists as expert spokesmen. Given the extent to which climatology appears to foster charlatanism, I am wary of all authors in the field.

I was especially eager to read Leroux's treatment of climate modelling. I have already written on why mathematicians are wary of the computer simulations responsible for the alarmist gloom and doom scenarios which lead so many people to advocate wrecking the world economy, abandoning democracy if necessary, in order to limit CO_2 output. My post on this subject dealt only with those universal features of the simulations that one could address without delving into the details of the models. I hope Leroux will shed more light on the nuts and bolts of the models.

Leroux's treatment of models (Chapter 7 of his book) is tinged with an antipathy to models qua models, which I consider misplaced. My objections are simply to the abuse of models. Leroux does provide us with more information about the models and their defects, although I assume that details such as grid sizes change monthly or yearly. I will rephrase and repackage Leroux's more coherent criticisms into a more mathematical framework.

Computer simulations of climate phenomena require dividing the atmosphere into a collection of volumes known as cells and assigning numerical data to each cell representing 'average' climate data for that cell for some time interval. At the time Leroux was writing, typical cell size ranged from hundreds to tens of thousands of cubic kilometers. He does not mention the typical time interval involved. Obviously, the smaller the cell and time step, the more reasonable is approximation of the climate within by some average. Ever increasing computer power is the only inherent limit on the number and therefore the size of the cells. Ideally, we would like to start with some initial approximate climate state, and compute the approximate evolution of the system by numerically approximating the solutions to the complex nonlinear fluid dynamics and other equations governing the system. Any phenomena which take place at smaller time or space scales than the time intervals or cells of our simulation cannot be modelled. Of course one can model such phenomena with a simulation adapted to the given phenomenon. Thus one could not use a simulation designed to model a century of global climate evolution to model the path of a hurricane. Instead, one uses a model adapted to the time and space scale of the hurricane, and corrects the simulation with new information several times a day.

In addition to errors arising from cell size and absence of real world initial data, climate evolution includes too many interactions to include in a realistic deterministic model. For example, the quantity of the main greenhouse gas, water vapor, depends on temperature, pressure, particulate matter, surface water, plant respiration, etc. These do not all admit simple modelling with numerical partial differential equations. Those features which are too complex for current deterministic models are ignored (the most honest path) or added into simulations by ad hoc mechanisms. These latter admit fine tuning to reach any desired conclusion.

Another source of error in simulations is the fact that the earth is not a closed system. Time varying solar radiation is the fundamental driver of our climate, but I am unaware of the existence of climate models that include realistic simulations of the complex dynamics of the sun's nuclear reactions.

Leroux appears to be bothered by the deterministic attitude of the climate modellers, a concern which I do not share. It seems reasonable to me that the extremely complex large scale dynamics of our climate stem result from small scale fundamental physical and chemical processes. Nonetheless, it is clear that since current climate models that are adapted to short time predictions are only crudely accurate for a few days, long term predictions have no value.

The more of Leroux I read, the less reliable he appears. His logic is generally quite poor. He frequently points out some weakness in the arguments of proponents of anthropogenic global warming, and then immediately concludes that CO_2 does not cause global warming, when, in fact, he has only countered an argument in support not actually presented an argument against. He also has a worrisome single factor explanation for most features of our climate. All phenomena of interest can be explained (according to Leroux) by his contribution to climatology: mobile polar highs. I have checked out a few books on atmospheric physics to make myself somewhat better able to analyze his claims. From my currently inexpert position, many of his assertions seem to be the atmospheric equivalent to the assertion that water runs down a mountain into a valley because the mountain is higher than the valley, and not because the valley is lower than the mountain. Such a distinction makes no sense to me; so, I need to learn more. Fortunately climate books are much lighter reading than math books, and hence can be read before bed without stimulating the brain enough to interfere with sleep.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

A mathematical perspective on snowflakes and global warming

Surprisingly, I have never heard support in the Mathematics faculty lounge for the global warming prognosticators of doom. I admit to baiting my colleagues on occasion with the standard game - attributing assorted random, ridiculous phenomena to global warming. None take the bait. My colleagues have been inoculated against much of the global warming hype by their prior exposure to bad mathematical modelling.

In the '90s, many applied mathematics groups wanted to hire experts in scientific computing. Computing power had increased so greatly that approximate solutions to many previously intractable problems became computable. Our department invited numerous experts in scientific computation to interview for a faculty position. Many talks took the following form. The speaker would discuss an algorithm for modelling some phenomenon, such as the formation of snowflakes, where the macro level physics was well understood, but how the basic physical laws translated into the observed structure of snowflakes was unknown. The speaker would postulate various mathematical rules for interpolating between the known physical regime and the unknown regime. The origin of these rules was usually obscure or ad hoc, and (key point!) involved numerous free parameters. The speaker would then run his algorithm, showing us many beautiful computer generated pictures, with many choices of the free parameters. The initial pictures looked as much like the Pillsbury Dough Boy as a snowflake. Finally, we would see a series of pictures where the parameters had been tuned to values so that the pictures looked like actual snowflakes, not Rorschach ink blots. The speaker declared victory.

The majority of our faculty agreed that these exercises had no scientific merit. Given any flexible model with enough free parameters, you can tune the parameters to obtain any desired result. It has no predictive value and no explanatory value. We made no hires of these parameter tuners. Most of them ended up working on Wall Street.

Turn now to global warming. What are the issues in the debate?
  1. Does CO_2 cause warming?
  2. Has there been significantly more warming post increase in CO_2 production than before?
  3. If there has been recent warming, is it due to CO_2?
  4. Will CO_2 induced warming lead to harmful consequences?
I have not heard disagreement on the first point. CO_2 has a warming affect. The second point is a question of data, and is the primary focus of most of the Climate Gate scandal. The integrity of the data on whether any significant warming has actually been measured is now suspect. The favorite alternate hypothesis to CO_2 induced warming is that warming is more likely to be a function of variation in solar output. My favorite analogy is that of lighting a match in a room with a furnace. Yes, the match increases the warmth of the room, but it is not as important as the furnace turning on and off. If clean data is ever produced showing there has actually been recent unusual warming, it has no weight unless it is demonstrated that it is caused by CO_2.

Finally we turn to the fourth item, which is closer to my expertise. The actual effect of CO_2 on the vastly complicated climate currently can't be directly known. The system is too large and too many details of the interactions are currently unknown. Hence the global warming brigade produces computer models with numerous ad hoc mathematical rules and many free parameters. They then tune the parameters until they get a snowflake! No, until they obtain any result they desire, from a 20 foot increase in sea level to a prediction of the winner of the World Series. Currently it is unknown if simple models of simple fluid flow give correct long time solutions. There is a million dollar prize for solving this problem. There is no scientific reason to respect these CO_2 models treating a vastly more complex system. Of course, if you want to test a model, the first question is: does it accurately predict the future? (They are constructed so that they always correctly 'predict' the past.) The global warming models have all failed this test.

Until the many microlevel details on how CO_2 and the environment interact (such as the various feedback mechanisms), no computer model can carry much weight. Of course, if one is designed that makes fantastically accurate long term predictions, then we have reason to put aside our doubts. Until these problems are overcome, vote down carbon taxes. If you want to hedge your bets, invest in Canadian real estate.